Ash
Weight: heavy; 43 lb./cu.ft.
Abrasion resistance: high
Ash is perhaps the best all-round wood for paddlemaking and
is the wood of choice for rugged tripping paddles. To work
with it, you will need sharp tools but even so, the grain
tends to pull easily if you plane it in the wrong direction.
This makes carving laminated ash paddles—where the grain
might run in several different irections—quite a frustrating
experience for the beginner.
Several species of ash are harvested commercially, but their
properties are quite similar. The wood can have a very attractive
figure (pattern of growth rings) but has an open grain that
makes it difficult to get an ultra-smooth finish. You will
be able to find pieces of ash in a number of shades, ranging
from almost white to a chocolaty brown. Combining these shades
by laminating can result in subtly beautiful paddles. Another
consequence of the open grain is that in laminated paddles,
glue gets squeezed into the texture of the wood, mating the
glue lines look ragged (although this is a problem only with
dark glues).
Probably the strongest wood available is "sports-grade"
ash (used for hockey sticks), which comes from rapidly growing
trees—6 to 10 rings per inch—harvested before
they are 80 years old.
Take care when sanding ash, because the dust is carcinogenic.
Basswood
Weight: light; 26 lb./cu.ft.
Abrasion resistance: low
Basswood has some very good and some very bad characteristics.
It is a truly easy wood to carve and, hence, a favorite for
decoy carvers. It is also quite light, reasonably strong and
inexpensive, at least in the United States. This is the good
news. Basswood reveals the wayward side of its character,
though, when it comes near water. It moves quite appreciably
in response to changes in moisture content and consequently
warps easily. As a result, basswood is perhaps best used stabilized
by other woods in a laminated paddle. It is also porous and
so sucks up water, especially from the exposed end grain at
the tip of the paddle if the protective coating (varnish or
oil) is damaged. Water creeps under varnish and will quickly
lift off the finish. It follows that basswood must be kept
well sealed.
Basswood makes light but high maintenance paddles.
Birch
Weight: heavy; 41 lb./cu.ft.
Abrasion resistance: high
Birch is a good wood for paddles, because it is strong and
relatively easy to carve.
Cedars
Weight: light; 22-25 lb./cu.ft.
Abrasion resistance: low
Properties vary markedly among the many different types of
cedar. White cedar is better than western red, because it
is not as brittle.
One-piece paddles that are to be used carefully in deep water
can be made with cedar. Cedars are also a fine choice for
feature strips in a blade, provided the tip is strongly splined
crossways to reduce the risk of splitting. These woods are
especially useful for paddles that are to be sheathed in fiberglass
— you can then take full advantage of their good looks
and light weight but not be at the mercy of their weakness.
Cedar dust is carcinogenic.
Cherry
Weight: medium; 38 lb./cu.ft.
Abrasion resistance: medium
Cherry is an attractive, mid-toned wood. It is relatively
easy to carve and very easy to sand. It is strong enough for
one-piece "Sunday best" paddles that are going to
be well looked after.
Douglas Fir
Weight: medium; 32 lb./cu.ft.
Abrasion resistance: medium
This wood is readily available in clear lengths. Pieces with
a low number of growth rings (fewer than 10 lines per inch)
have grain that pulls rather easily under the plane. Douglas
fir has a reputation for splitting rather easily, and so it
is probably best used as strips in laminated paddles, where
it introduces an unusual tan color. It is best avoided in
whitewater paddles unless they are to be fiberglassed.
Mahogany
Weight: medium/variable
Abrasion resistance: medium
The many species of mahogany are generally rather weak wood
best used for dark feature strips.
Maple
Weight: heavy; 45 lb./cu.ft.
Abrasion resistance: high
Maple makes very good one-piece paddles and is also useful
for exterior strips on laminated blades incorporating softer
woods. It is quite easy to carve with sharp tools and sands
to a smooth finish. If not kept well sealed against moisture,
it has a slight tendency to split at the blade tip. A good
choice for working paddles.
Pine
Weight: medium; 30 lb./cu.ft
Abrasion resistance: low
The general name "pine" covers several species
of pine and fir, and their properties vary quite widely. Oregon
and Columbian pine have been reported to splinter rather easily.
The wood is readily workable because it is relatively soft
and the grain cuts predictably, and so it is an excellent
choice for the novice paddlemaker. Wood with a high resin
content has the nasty habit of clogging sandpaper quickly.
Spruce
Weight: light; 24-27 lb./cu.ft.
Abrasion resistance: low
Sitka spruce is by far the best of the several different
types of spruce available. A spruce paddle is light and springy;
the wood represents a good compromise between strength and
lightness. It is a recommended wood for light-use paddles.